Last Sunday, I played guitar and sang at our contemporary worship service. I don’t play in church very often, and I don’t claim to be very good. In fact, I play and sing so rarely, my meager abilities are always on the far-to-rusty side. But, in spite of my rust and musical limitations, I love the rare opportunities I lead people in worshiping God in song. At one point, Sunday, as I sang, I was overcome with emotion and nearly cried. Crying and singing is really, really hard!
While I don’t play and sing in worship, often, I do preach on an almost-weekly basis. Preaching is my true passion. I hear some preachers struggle with sermon preparation. I hear some preachers struggle with sermon writing. I hear some preachers struggle with nerves, delivering sermons. I hear some preachers are worn down by preaching EVERY week. I don’t struggle with any of that. I love it, from beginning to end! I’m not claiming to be a great preacher – I just love doing it! If I could give 100% of my time to preaching prep and delivery, I gladly would!
In fact, I enjoy all facets of worship – traditional/liturgical and modern/contemporary. I love planning worship. I love spontaneous worship. I love singing hymns and contemporary worship songs. I love traditional liturgy and technology. I love the “smells and bells” of “high” church worship, and hands lifted in praise, in contemporary services.
I love planning worship. I love leading worship. I love worshipping from the pew. I love all of it.
But, in spite of my passion for worship, I have growing sense something about worship isn’t “working.”
Throughout my entire Christian life and ministry, Sunday morning worship – regardless of form or style – has been the primary function of every local church I’ve known and served. Yes, churches have meetings, Bible studies, missions, fellowship, etc. throughout the week. But, worship draws the crowd. Worship requires most of the church’s collective time, energy, focus, talent, facility, and funding.
What’s the largest (and least used) building on a church campus? The sanctuary. What’s the largest portion of the budget? When you add up everything – from salaries, to utilities, to property maintenance and insurance, to the cost of music – I suspect Sunday morning worship represents the largest chunk of a church’s expenditures. Why do churches require so much parking? Only one reason: Sunday mornings.
Likewise, throughout my entire Christian life and ministry, worship attendance – across the nation and across denominations – has been, and is, statistically in decline. Sanctuaries and church parking lots are less and less full on Sunday mornings. Even the super-successful, fastest-growing mega-churches are noting a decline in weekly worship attendance.
One reason is, younger people aren’t attending worship services like the older generations. We’ve all heard about the growing numbers “nones” and “dones.”
Another reason is the growing affluence in our country. In spite of many claiming to have financial struggles, overall, more and more people can afford to travel, participate in sports, buy a boat, go to a concert or movie, renovate their home, pay to run a marathon, own a boat, or go to the beach for the weekend. When you can’t afford to do those things, you might be more likely to stay home and attend worship. But, when you can, you do.
Another reason is technology. Now, thanks to the internet, you can watch or listen to the very best preachers and worship bands, often “live,” from the comfort of your own home and Laz-i-boy recliner, in your boxers and bathrobe, rather than getting dressed, dragging the kids, dealing with the traffic, sitting in a hard pew, and being hounded about giving your tithes and offerings. Oh yeah, you can avoid human contact too!
Which leads to another reason: consumerism. Rather than viewing worship as something we do, together, in service and duty to God, we’ve turned worship into a spectator sport – a form of spiritual entertainment. If worship is just entertainment, we’ll never compete with what the world has to offer. Whether it’s a 3-D surround-sound movie theater, a sporting complex, or Walt Disney World, church-as-entertainment can’t compete. Nor should we. We aren’t in the entertainment business. But, as long as we approach worship as consumers, rather than contributors, worship will be little else.
And, another reason is the current climate of divisiveness in our country. We are as divided and polarized as ever. I find everything I say “from the pulpit” is scrutinized more than ever before, for signs of hidden biases and agendas. I do have biases and agendas. But, they aren’t hidden. You don’t have to search for them. I’m usually pretty open and honest! If people don’t agree with the pastor’s preaching, rather than being challenged to think and reconsider their beliefs, they just leave.
I’m sure there are as many reasons for NOT regularly attending a worship service, as there are people who regularly do not attended worship services.
So, I’m beginning to wonder, what if it’s time to reevaluate the Sunday worship gathering as the PRIMARY function of a local church? I’m NOT suggesting we should stop worshipping together. Rather, I wonder if, in the not-too-distant future, corporate worship will be in smaller, less formal settings, and not necessarily in church sanctuaries, on Sunday mornings.
Perhaps worship will happen more organically, and even more frequently, when Christians gather to share a meal, or for a small group Bible study, or to serve together. I wonder if worship, in the future, will be more relational, more face-to-face, more conversational. If wonder if worship will be less professionally driven – by paid preachers and musicians – and more lay-led. I wonder if worship will happen less in sanctuaries, and more in homes, parks, coffee shops, yoga studios, gardens, around dinner tables.
And, I wonder if Church will become more dispersed; perhaps, fewer large-group gatherings, and many more smaller gatherings for study, service, worship, prayer, fellowship, accountability, etc.
Think of worship in the Bible. Yes, we can all think of some large gatherings – the Sermon on the Mount, the day of Pentecost, the annual Jewish festivals in Jerusalem. But, I get the impression that most corporate worship, in biblical times, wasn’t very much like what it’s become.
Please hear me. I’m not trying to be prophetic, predictive, or prescriptive. I’m not implying any “shoulds.” I love the ministry of corporate worship, and am saddened to watch it decline. It’s what I know and what I love, and I hate the idea of losing it.
But, I’m just wondering. I’m wondering.
I do think there’ll continue to be a place for the Sunday worship gathering, at least in the foreseeable future. I do think corporate worship continues to be worthy of our best efforts. I still think there’s a role, thankfully, for professional preachers, worship leaders, organists, etc. I still think there are opportunities to offer both traditional (and contemporary) worship services, as well as new and innovative worship experiences. There are still churches with growing worship attendances, and we should pay attention to how and why that’s happening.
But, perhaps its time to expand our minds. Perhaps its time to expand our understanding of what worship is and who it’s for. Perhaps its time to expand our vision for what Church can be. Perhaps – brace yourself – it’s time for change.
I’d love to hear your thoughts.